Leslie Kasperowicz holds a BA in Social Sciences from the University of Winnipeg. She spent several years as a Farmers Insurance CSR, gaining a solid understanding of insurance products including home, life, auto, and commercial and working directly with insurance customers to understand their needs. She has since used that knowledge in her more than ten years as a writer, largely in the insurance...

Full Bio →

Written by

UPDATED: Jul 14, 2021

Advertiser Disclosure

It’s all about you. We want to help you make the right coverage choices.

Advertiser Disclosure: We strive to help you make confident car insurance decisions. Comparison shopping should be easy. We are not affiliated with any one car insurance provider and cannot guarantee quotes from any single provider. Our partnerships don’t influence our content. Our opinions are our own. To compare quotes from many different companies please enter your ZIP code on this page to use the free quote tool. The more quotes you compare, the more chances to save.

Editorial Guidelines: We are a free online resource for anyone interested in learning more about car insurance. Our goal is to be an objective, third-party resource for everything car insurance-related. We update our site regularly, and all content is reviewed by car insurance experts.

In every state and city, the cheapest car insurance broker for one driver and one type of car will not be the cheapest for another. Some insurance brokers are cheaper for middle aged and elderly drivers and others may offer the best prices for youthful drivers.

A few companies offer better prices for licensed drivers with negative histories, but are not competitive in other areas. It is important to be mindful of the benefit to insurance companies when licensed drivers are unaware they qualify for better rates elsewhere.

Aside from driving records, driver milestones have the biggest impact on insurance premiums. Since insurance brokers treat milestones differently, the best way to save money on car insurance cost is to research individual broker prices as milestones approach by using insurance comparison websites.

It would be very difficult to regularly conduct this type of personalized research without the internet.

Use the FREE comparison tool above to start your search for quotes today!

Milestones that Affect Car Insurance Prices

  • Career change: A new job that requires more or less driving will affect the rates offered by some insurance companies. Professions that require transporting clients or customers will require higher liability protection which will cost more.
  • Residence change: Insurance rates for some states can be four to five times higher than others depending on individual state laws. Within regions, certain zip codes have higher rates than others.
  • Years of driving experience and age: Newly licensed drivers who are 18 to 25 years old have the highest rates almost everywhere. Drivers under the age of 18 typically cannot purchase car insurance independently. As driving experience increases with age, insurance rates will decrease each renewal date following a birthday. The 26th birthday usually comes with the biggest reduction in a car insurance premium.
  • Marital status: Married people often get lower rates just because they are married in addition to qualifying for multi-car discounts.

Enter your ZIP code below to view companies that have cheap auto insurance rates.

 Secured with SHA-256 Encryption

Best Prices for a High Mileage Driver in Mid-Priced State

Clare is 42 and sells real estate in Santa Rosa, California. She uses her 2013 GMC Acadia for showing property and logs over 25,000 miles per year. Clare needs a premium level coverage with high liability limits.

Clare can get premium level coverage for these monthly payments in Santa Rosa:

  1. USAA -$122.00
  2. Allstate -$140.00
  3. State Farm -$162.00
  4. 21st Century – $195.00
  5. Geico – $206.00
  6. Mid-Century -$214.00
  7. Liberty Mutual -$217.00
  8. AAA- $224.00

Because Clare does not have a military connection to get USAA insurance, her next step is to call or fill out individual online requests from the companies who are able to offer her insurance.

Clare should not make a final decision until she receives at least three individual quotes. The cheapest car insurance broker for Clare will not be the cheapest for the next driver in this article.

Best Prices for Young Drivers in Mid-Priced State

Jack is 19 years old, lives in Boulder, Colorado and drives a 2007 Jeep Cherokee. Basic coverage for Jack is available for these payments from these companies:

  1. USAA – $127.00
    Geico – $133.00
    American Family – $223.00
    State Farm – $243.00
    Allstate -$261.00
    Progressive -$359.00
    Farmers -$409.00
    Safeco -$525.00

Jack’s father is a veteran which gives Jack a military connection making USAA insurance the best price for Jack.

One of Jack’s co-workers is 26 and also lives in Boulder. His online research finds these monthly prices for his Ford F 250:

  1. USAA – $87.00
  2. Geico – $98.00
  3. State Farm -$103.00
  4. American Family – $143.00
  5. Allstate – $148.00
  6. Safeco – $192.00
  7. Farmers – $228.00
  8. Progressive -$254.00

Best Prices for Family of Drivers with Accident History in High Priced State

The Mitchells live in Providence, Rhode Island. Michael and Nancy are 45 and 47 years old and live with their 17 and 19 year old sons who are both licensed to drive.

Because car insurance is so expensive in Rhode Island, the boys share the 3rd car which is still registered to Nancy. The family cars are a 2011 Subaru Forester, a 2010 Honda Odyssey and a 2003 Honda Civic.

In October of 2013, Nancy was involved in an at-fault accident with no injuries, but property damage exceeded $2,000.00. Michael and Nancy can get insurance from these companies in Providence for these monthly payments:

  1. Geico – $578.00
  2. Travelers -$789.00
  3. Progressive -$815.00
  4. Amica – $1,127.00
  5. Allstate – $1,159.00
  6. Liberty Mutual -$1,329.00
  7. Nationwide -$1,337.00

Enter your ZIP code below to view companies that have cheap auto insurance rates.

 Secured with SHA-256 Encryption

Best Prices for Empty Nester Couple in Low Priced State

Mark and Deborah live in Wake Forest, North Carolina. Mark is 65 and Deborah is 61. They own 2012 Mercedes Benz SLK Roadster and a 2013 BMW X5 3.5 SUV. Mark and Deborah are about to retire and have been making an effort to reduce expenses.

After conducting online research, they find their loyalty to the Farm Bureau is costing them a lot of money.

  1. Geico – $141.00
  2. Allstate – $207.00
  3. Nationwide -$221.00
  4. State Farm – $224.00
  5. Farm Bureau -$276.00

Do’s and Don’ts for Finding the Cheapest Car Insurance Brokers

  • Do go to your state insurance website to see if there is a comparison function for insurance rates.
  • Do search one or more commercial insurance comparison sites in addition to official state sites who offer online comparison.
  • Do research insurance company reviews to evaluate other customer experiences.
  • Do online searches before renewal date when any insurance milestone is in the near future?
  • Don’t assume that friends, co-workers and family member’s good deals are the same good deals for you.
  • Don’t wait until a premium increase notice arrives. Shop before the milestone passes.
  • Don’t take for granted that the company with the best rate in one location will be the best in another.
  • Don’t be afraid to try a new company. Many insurance companies with great prices only offer insurance in certain areas.
  • Don’t wait until you feel like you are paying too much money. Perform advance research now to be sure you are paying the least amount possible from the beginning.
  • Don’t be taken in by claims made by television advertisements. The familiar “Save 15 percent in 15 minutes” applies to very few consumers, if any at all.

The internet is the best friend of all committed comparison shoppers. The vast range of car insurance premium prices is proof that timely online comparison shopping is still only performed by a small percentage of insurance consumers.

Use the FREE tool below to start comparing quotes instantly! Simply enter your ZIP code to get started now.